Hello everyone.
We've been talking about the gender pay gap for years now, and I'll admit it's getting harder to find something new to say. The latest ONS figures show that the gap among full-time employees has narrowed again, to 6.8%, which is welcome progress. But for women aged 50-59, it's risen to 11%. So, there's clearly more to understand about what happens as women's careers progress.
Two things caught my attention recently that feel like part of that story.
The first was research from Cambridge University looking at the scientists named in GCSE science exam specifications. Across the specifications examined, 85 men were named and just one woman. Rosalind Franklin, in case you're wondering. At A-level, it was 178 men and 3 women.
This isn't because women haven't made important scientific discoveries. Sometimes their contributions are included without their names being credited. Now, this is about exam specifications, not everything taught in classrooms, and the research doesn't establish a direct link with girls' subject choices. But still. What does it tell girls about who succeeds, whose achievements matter and where they might belong?
It got me thinking about something I hear an awful lot in women's leadership development. "You need to be more confident."
I've always thought this was pretty terrible feedback. For a start, what does it actually mean? Confident about what? Speaking up? Challenging your boss? Putting yourself forward for promotion? But there's a bigger problem. It assumes confidence is something missing in the woman, rather than something shaped by her experiences.
Confidence doesn't develop in isolation. It develops through being encouraged, listened to, trusted and given opportunities. And it can be undermined by those same experiences. If you've repeatedly had your ideas overlooked, watched less experienced colleagues progress ahead of you or learned that speaking up comes with consequences, might that affect how readily you put yourself forward next time? Of course it might.
But here's what I find even more frustrating. Women can be confident and still be overlooked. A man is assertive. A woman is aggressive. A man is decisive. A woman is controlling. A man knows his worth. A woman is difficult.
We encourage women to speak up, but what happens when they do? Are their contributions taken seriously? Are we comfortable with women demonstrating the very confidence we've told them they need?
The second thing that caught my attention was at BIMA Assembly last week, listening to Aliya Vigor-Robertson, Founder Partner at Journey HR, talking about women in the digital and technology industries. The discussion touched on the motherhood penalty, burnout and the work organisations still need to do around the experience of parents returning to work. That last point particularly resonated on a personal level (yes, me too) and a professional level (we hear this from the women we coach daily).
Returning from maternity leave can be a significant transition. Confidence may have taken a knock. You're navigating different responsibilities, perhaps questioning where you fit and what you want next. Coaching before and after maternity leave can be enormously helpful. But what about the organisation?
Has the manager been supported to handle that transition well? Are returning mothers still getting the same opportunities? Are assumptions being made about their ambition, commitment or availability? Because there's only so much individual coaching can achieve if the workplace itself doesn't change.
And this doesn't stop at maternity leave. Women navigating menopause may not be getting the understanding, flexibility and support they need to keep progressing. If experienced women reduce their hours, step back from opportunities or leave altogether, that has implications for their earnings and for who reaches senior roles.
And this feels particularly relevant as organisations prepare for gender equality action plans, covering both the gender pay gap and support for employees experiencing menopause. For employers with 250 or more employees, these are now scheduled to become mandatory from March 2027 for relevant public authorities and April 2027 for private and voluntary-sector employers, subject to the necessary legislation. For years we've been asking organisations to report their gender pay gap. Now we're moving towards asking them to explain what they're going to do about it. Which is a good thing.
But you can't create a meaningful action plan if you don't understand what's driving the problem. And I'm not convinced the levers for change are always obvious.
You might conclude you need more women in senior roles. But why aren't they there? Are women not applying? Are they missing out on opportunities? Are promotion decisions influenced by narrow assumptions about leadership potential? Are talented women leaving after maternity leave? Perhaps it's several things. And perhaps the answers sit in the everyday behaviours, decisions and unwritten rules that shape organisational culture.
The data tells you where the gaps are. It doesn't necessarily tell you why they exist. Getting underneath that requires curiosity, honest conversations and sometimes support from someone who can bring an outside perspective.
I absolutely believe in helping women develop confidence. I've seen how transformative coaching can be. But there's a difference between helping someone grow and suggesting they're the problem that needs fixing. And I'm getting a bit tired of the assumption that women are the ones who need to change.
If we're serious about closing the gender pay gap, we need to understand what's actually happening in our organisations, not just introduce another initiative and hope it works. Because perhaps the first step isn't asking women to be more confident. Perhaps it's asking ourselves what needs to change so they don't have to work quite so hard to be heard, recognised and given the opportunities they deserve.
Rox x